
I’ve been working in Birmingham educational system for a year now. At first with children that have special needs, then in a pupil referral unit. Admittedly I haven’t mentioned this much here for three main reasons.
1. Its good material and that’s being saved for the inevitable autobiography titled “this might have happened; but I have taken a lot of drugs”
2. its not fair on the kids who have a hard enough time as it is without a closet drunk on the internet being sarcastic about it.
3. I didn’t want this blog to be about my job, there are far better blogs out there (recommend slow children at play – hasn’t updated in about two years but go back and read the archives.
But there is something I need to get off my chest, I’m still quite new at my job and am still learning, but this seems wrong to me. recently we received a new pupil to the centre, who, after testing had been put in the extra support class for literacy. During extra testing and by observing this guy it became apparent to both me and the teacher that he’s dyslexic. Great, I say, now we can get him tested properly and get him the support he needs. No says the teacher. It turns out that the Birmingham LEA does not provide dyslexia testing for young adults, ever, until they get to university age and the cost is shared by the uni.
Their reasoning is that, because the support you would give a child with really low literacy levels is the same as the support you would give a child with the same problem because of dyslexia, apparently it’s not worth paying for the test.
I’m going to leave the issue of whether the kids that need that need extra support are getting it (hint: I don’t think so) and focus on the issues that I, personally have experience of, because I, dear reader, I am a dyslexic – if you don’t believe me I’ve gone to the trouble of tagging the posts that were written during the period of my life where I discovered this.
Reading back those old posts I am struck at how relieving it was. Finding out I was dyslexic meant that all those teachers that told me I was lazy or unmotivated were wrong, it explained why I sometimes pronounce words strangely or why, in my twenties, I still didn’t understand what a syllable was. But the children not being tested are being denied this relief, the explanation as to why the things that other people find easy are so tough, denied the opportunity to feel proud of achieving as much as they have despite the handicap rather than the shame of competing and comparing themselves in a game rigged in someone else’s favour.
Secondly when I was diagnosed I was told exactly what my weakness are, making it much easier to target them and discover strategies around them. Also the diagnosis enabled me at secondary education to access the extra support, marking and testing allowances, and project time extensions. The attitude that the stratagems for dyslexics and people with less than average literacy skills, for example if English is a second or third language, is based on the false presumption that all dyslexics needs are similar and met by the established stratagems.
Also what about kids like me? I was in higher education before I was diagnosed, struggling through both school and college. If a young person isn’t doing really badly but just muddling along they will never offered for special learning support and always aspiring to average, and never realising their potential. If we are not looking for dyslexia we will never find it.
So what am I to do? Well , mostly support the literacy teacher who spends huge chunks of free time lesson planning, so we can give the tests that are deemed inconsequential by the LEA, try to build up our kids confidence by talking to them like equals and letting them know the problems I have, and wait for public opinions to change so dyslexia is seen as a real condition instead of a lack of concentration and effort from the person in question.

7 comments
Comments feed for this article
December 12, 2008 at 2:12 pm
uphilldowndale
This makes me very angry, some kids with dyslexia (OMG, spellchecker isn’t working on this, bear with me) will haul themselves through school to uni with out any interventions, others will fall by the wayside, crushed, Dispirited and thoroughly pissed off by the education system.
I was in my 40’s when I was assessed as dyslexic, it was only through watching my own son’s struggles that I started to understand that dyslexia is so much more than ‘a little trouble’ with spelling. It blew me away when I realised just how much impact my dyslexia has had on my life. I wish I had known just what my weaknesses were and how to navigate them, because that knowledge gives confidence and empowerment and that’s 99% of the battle.
I had rather hoped it was different now, in education, but speaking with teachers I can see that little in their training gives them the skills to help dyslexic students, which is a tragedy because a good repertoire of learning skills and tactics, are good news for any student not just the dyslexic.
You can find some dyslexia tagged posts on my blog.
December 13, 2008 at 11:15 am
Tessa
Leicestershire do not officially recognise dyslexia (so I’ve been told) but prefer to label kids as ‘poor readers’. I spend many hours supporting parents who are frustrated with the attitude of parents and schools to their child who has been called ‘lazy’ , ‘inattentive’, ‘disruptive’. Sadly teachers do not see these behaviours for what they are – defense against being put in a fail situation day after day. It is unbelievable in this day and age but most teachers are still not able to identify dyslexics/dyscalculics.
Perhaps I am being harsh because there is no agreed cause for dyslexia and many support strategies appear to contradict each other. However I do think schools should be more flexible in their approach to teaching reading and writing. For those that struggle with phonics why should doing it ‘slower and for longer’ be any help. Would not a visual approach be worth trying?
I’ve been successful helping dyslexics/dyscalculics and ADHD children and adults but I have become increasingly angry at schools because of the emotional damage inflicted on these kids who just learn differently.
December 13, 2008 at 7:37 pm
uphilldowndale
As dyslexia is recognised under the disability discrimination act 1995
http://www.personneltoday.com/articles/2007/09/12/42089/dyslexia-and-the-disability-discrimination-act-paterson-v-the-commissionr-of-police-of-the-metropoli.html (I wish I could do links!)
you would think Leicestershire were on very dodgy ground with that policy.
I really hoped it had all moved on ‘from my day’ it’s very sad to hear that it is not always the case.
December 23, 2008 at 3:34 am
HileryJane
In my region in Scotland I run a Dyslexia Support Service: an Outreach service attempting to support teachers change the way they teach to accommodate learners with dyslexia.
We don’t use the word ‘diagnosis’ but ‘identification’. We do give formal standardised tests, but these are only part of a battery of assessments based principally on formative approaches.
As we believe there are as many differences between those with dyslexia as there are elsewhere in the population, there is no one way to tackle the difficulties they may encounter in school.
I agree it’s important to recognise the different approaches to learning that those with dyslexia take and to help them discover strategies to circumvent the barrier of print and that these are different from the way we might tackle helping a young person with global literacy delay.
Nonetheless, effective strategies for a dyslexic are also likely to be effective for all learners.
January 16, 2009 at 12:48 pm
mrskarmadillo
I take it you heard about this muppet? http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/manchester/7828121.stm
*sigh*
January 16, 2009 at 1:02 pm
probdrunk
somebody mentioned it in the pub last night, but i hadn’t read it until now.
for fucks sake
Yes, synthetic phonics is a very good method of teaching litracy. That is for people that can hear them. For people like me who have difficulty hearing the differant parts of words its fucking useless*
please excuse the bad spelling, not on my home machine, so no spellcheck.
*this is the reason those that know me will sometimes say i mumble, or i mispronounce some words or still dont know how to break a word up into syllables.
January 28, 2009 at 2:03 pm
Clip show « Edge Trinkets
[...] – I saddle up my high horse again and potentially risk my [...]